Should We Get Back Together?

My boyfriend and I had been dating for about a year and a half and although we had the typical arguments we were still very much in love with each other. We had talked about marriage and he was "saving for a ring". Then, in late May, he freaked out and decided he needed to "see other people" and "see what else is out there" before he could settle down. I was devastated but was able to move on. Before long, we were both dating other people and had very little contact with each other.

Then, in mid July we started talking again. It began innocently enough but quickly turned into "I love you and miss you" and sleeping together. We both agreed that we missed each other but it didn't feel like the "right timing" for us to get back together so we each went on with our independent lives. That lasted about a month before we felt like we just had to see each other again. And again, we decided that as much as we still loved each other the timing wasn't right.

A couple weeks ago we started talking again for the 3rd time since we broke up. He told me that he felt that he was always "being drawn toward me" and that he could hardly remember why we broke up in the first place. We've been sort of "seeing each other" since then and it feels as perfect and blissful as it did in the very beginning.

He still has doubts about whether or not we should "end up together" and is reluctant to commit to giving it another shot despite how happy we've been lately. I think that despite all of our issues, we are lucky to have found someone who we love so much and click with so well and the rest can be worked out. I also think that we'll never really know unless we do give it another shot to see if it will work and if we don't, we may spend the rest of our lives wondering what might have been....